Director - Brotherhood Mutual

Brotherhood Mutual is an innovative for profit company working to insure America’s churches and Christian ministries in order to advance the Kingdom. Brotherhood mutual seeks a Director to join the current board of directors in leading this organization to greater Kingdom impact.

This fast-growing organization is focused solely on serving the faith-based community. With multiple companies and products created specifically to undergird Kingdom work, there is significant complexity in operations which require an engaged and experienced Director to bring wisdom and a high degree of business acumen into executive level decisions. A passionate executive, capable of balancing the vision for serving non-profit organizations with the demands of stewarding a large organization will be invited to steer the future vision of the company.


Brotherhood Mutual insures America’s churches and related ministries. We have for more than 100 years. But there’s more. From our perspective, insurance is more than a commercial endeavor. It’s a platform to accomplish our mission: to help America’s churches and related ministries build the Kingdom.

In serving our clients, we will uphold the Biblical values upon which the company was founded:

Be the Leader in developing and providing ministry-focused insurance products and risk management services.

Build the Kingdom by helping churches and ministries focus on changing lives and fulfilling the Great Commission.

Bless the Laborers by creating a corporate culture, compensation structure, and ministry opportunities designed to further personal and professional purpose.

What does it mean to be a mutual insurance company?

A mutual insurance company is not owned by shareholders, but rather by policyholders—the churches and ministries we serve. Policyholders’ premium dollars help protect and rebuild ministries in the wake of life’s storms. At Brotherhood Mutual, they hold themselves accountable to policyholders, and the promise that they will be there for them when they need it most. Today, Brotherhood Mutual insures more than 60,000 churches and related ministries and offers its MinistryFirst property and liability coverages in 47 states and the District of Columbia. The intentions of the company’s founders live on in an organization that still cares about protecting its ministry customers from fires and storms—and much more.



Fort Wayne is the second-largest city in the state of Indiana, and has routinely been cited as a great place to live. Money Magazine, the U.S. Conference of Mayors, All-America City Awards, Business Week, and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development have all awarded the community for the outstanding quality of life.

In addition, Fort Wayne boasts of one of the lowest costs of living in the country, making it possible for residents to own their dream homes. Top-notch medical care is available for six area hospitals boasting cutting edge cancer and heart centers and Fort Wayne International Airport connects the city to business and vacation destinations around the world.

Combine the progressive business climate, solid educational opportunities, affordable living and vibrant entertainment options, and its easy to understand why Brotherhood Mutual retains its headquarters in Fort Wayne, Indiana!


The next Brotherhood Mutual Director has the opportunity for exponential Kingdom impact as they bring their executive level finance experience and a high degree of leadership and vision casting into alignment with a passion for serving the Church and related ministries.

This is a unique opportunity requiring a willingness to learn the industry, build relationships with current board members and key constituents. The next Director will advise Brotherhood Mutual with honest and helpful input, be fully prepared for and attend all board meetings and bring innovative ideas and leadership to expand current products and services to support the future growth of the organization.

Board of Directors Focus

  • Steer the vision for the next 10 years

  • Financial stability and sustainability of the organization

  • Assure the health and relevance of the organization through succession planning and employee development

  • Identify, develop and cultivate partnerships with other faith based service providers

Role & Responsibilities

  • Embrace the fiduciary responsibilities of serving on a public board

  • Be engaged to bring wisdom, insight and guidance

  • Invest in learning the church industry including insurance, payroll and administration

  • Be passionate about fulfilling the mission statement: To help America’s churches and related ministries build the kingdom


  • Passion for serving the church

  • Collaborative leader

  • Well connected and eager to share the mission and services of Brotherhood Mutual with their network

To view the full opportunity profile

click here

Apply Online

AGORA Search Group is a Colorado Springs search firm providing executive search and selection services to churches, and faith-based non-profits throughout the world.

Rob Lauer is leading the Brotherhood Mutual search. Rob founded AGORA in 2000 and provides nearly 30 years of executive search, church consulting, and pastoral ministry experience for our clients. Rob has a passion to serve organizations with an emphasis on building relationships throughout the executive search process versus the typical transactional approach. He is adamant, believing not every great leader or pastor…is a great fit…for a great organization or church. As a result, he and his team invest significant time matching exceptional leaders with outstanding organizations.

For further details regarding this role, please contact:

Rob Lauer


Apple Online

return to searches page